NEW

Statute of Limitations Proposed for Legacy of Troubles

Statute of Limitations Proposed for Legacy of the Troubles During the Prime Minister’s Question time on 15 July, PM Johnson announced that the government would be bringing forth a statute of limitations in regard to occurencess committed before the Good Friday...

Church of England Considering Legislation Regarding Parishes Seeking Input on Proposals

Church of England Considering Legislation Regarding Parishes Seeking Input on Proposals   Input has been requested on the proposals to change the current legislation regarding parishes within the Church of England.  The review of the Mission and Pastoral Measure...

GAFCON Australia to Support Diocese for Those Forced from Anglican Church of Australia

GAFCON Australia to Support Diocese for Those Forced from Anglican Church of Australia Gafcon Australia has outlined its plan to support Anglicans who leave the Anglican Church of Australia over doctrinal revision which overturns the plain teaching of Scripture. At an...

Church of England Evangelical Council Reacts to Unorthodox Remarks by Bp of Liverpool

Church of England Evangelical Council Reacts to Unorthodox Remarks by Bishop of Liverpool The Church of England Evangelical Council has responded to a widely criticised public address and subsequent apology made last month by the Rt Revd Paul Bayes, Bishop of...

Questions Out of LFF, Letter to the Editor

Dear Sir, I read the first article from Anglican Futures, regarding the document, Living In Love and Faith, [LLF] EC 8083. I found the article helpful, well presented and gives a clear overview of the document.  However, I found myself seriously disquieted and I raise...

Kenyan Bishop Appeals for Orphan Aid: Parental Deaths Due to HIV

Kenyan Bishop Appeals for Orphan Aid Parental Deaths Due to HIV  The Rt Revd John Orina Omangi, Bishop of the Kisii Missionary District in Eastern Kenya is appealing for assistance in caring for 100 children orphaned by the widespread HIV problem in the area.  Kisii...

Christianity & Craft Freemasonry, A Pastoral Guide for Christian Ministers

Christianity and Craft Freemasonry A Pastoral Guide for Christian Ministers Gerard Moate Latimer Trust, 2021 (ISBN: 9781906327705, 70pp) By 1964 a national commission of enquiry estimated the existence of 50,000 books and pamphlets on freemasonry. This literature has,...

Forgotten Reformer: Myles Coverdale

Forgotten Reformer: Miles Coverdale Geoffrey Main Self-published, 2021 (ISBN: 9781916873704, 228pp) Episcopal biographies are always an enjoyable read, not least those of bishops who are better known for their non-episcopal work. Coverdale is of course best known for...

And Just When You Thought You’d Heard Everything, Bats Communications Officer

Whilst considering reducing the number of clergy nationwide, the Church of England is advertising for someone to be employed as its, “Bats in Churches Communications Officer”.  The post, which is located in London, pays between £31,857 and £34,255 (pro rata).  The...

Pilgrim’s Proces: Baptism Depths of Meaning by Peter Sanlon

In my last column we looked at the Lord’s Supper.  Today, we take a look at the other sign our Lord Jesus instituted among us.  These signs, or sacraments, which God gives his people are both simple and profound. In their simplicity, God's grace is powerfully...

Prudence Dailey Commentary: Safetyism, A Sacred Value?

Prudence Dailey Commentary

“Safetyism: a Sacred Value?”

 

Since last March we have been living in extraordinary times, facing not only the first global pandemic in living memory, but also unprecedented restrictions on our most basic liberties. Never before have entire populations of democratic countries—including the healthy—been confined to their homes, prohibited from hugging their loved ones, forced to shutter their businesses and even barred from public worship. In the first weeks and months of the pandemic, nobody knew quite what we were dealing with, and it appeared that additional lives might be lost due to health services being overrun with COVID patients who might otherwise have been successfully treated, so it seemed reasonable to try and ‘flatten the curve’ while extra capacity (in the UK, the Nightingale Hospitals, which were the end hardly used) was built up.

As the disease became better understood, however, there were more and more aspects of the government’s strategy that appeared to make no sense. With mortality heavily concentrated at the upper end of the age bracket, such that the average age of death from the novel coronavirus was several years higher than average life expectancy overall, why was it thought necessary or justified to ‘lock down’ the young—even children, barely susceptible to COVID at all—and the economically active? And why were the economic and social costs of lockdown polities not weighed against the lives potentially saved, given that poverty, lack of opportunity and mental ill-health themselves lead to increased mortality? Such calculations may on the surface seem heartless, but they are a necessary and well-established element of public policy: the National Health Service uses the concept ‘quality adjusted life years’, or QALYs, to make objective decisions about the use of finite resources; but no such calculation was even attempted in relation to the response to COVID.

Such apparent lack of rationality has led to the rise of various conspiracy theories, from the almost plausible to the frankly bizarre. In reality, though, such hypotheses require far more consciously co-ordinated global effort and organisation than mankind is truly capable of; whereas it requires no effort or organisation at all simply to make a catastrophic mess-up.

The real culprit is ‘safetyism’—a term originally coined by Jonathan Haidt and Greg Lukianoff in their 2018 book The Coddling of the American Mind to describe an ethos which regards safety as a sacred value, such that it can never be traded off against other moral or practical concerns. Haidt and Lukianoff used it originally in relation to such phenomena as ‘helicopter parenting’, and the demand for ‘safe spaces’ on college campuses; but it can be applied just as well to the response to COVID.

Junior Health Minister Lord Bethell let the cat out of the bag in the House of Lords when the Bishop of Leeds, in the context of a question as to when singing in church might once again be permitted, asked:

‘We have learned to live with acceptable death rates from flu and other seasonal diseases. Will the Government do some work on what might be an acceptable death rate from COVID in future and be up-front with the country as to what that might be? I think we can take it.’

…to which the Minister replied

‘…I really do not accept the concept of an acceptable death rate. That is not how we play the health system in this country. We are here to save lives; that is our priority. There is a balance between the economy, freedom and lives, but as a Health Minister my starting point is to save lives.’

The Minister’s reply is nonsense, really—if the government truly believed there was literally no acceptable death rate, the speed limit would be reduced to 10 miles per hour everywhere—but, in a culture that seeks to hide from the inevitability of death, it is emotionally appealing nonsense. The Bishop understood what the Minister did not want to admit: namely that, as the Psalmist says, ‘The days of our age are threescore years and ten; and though men be so strong that they come to fourscore years : yet is their strength then but labour and sorrow; so soon passeth it away, and we are gone’ (Psalm 90 v 10). 

The intrinsic moral worth of the life of an 85-year-old is, of course, worth every bit as much as that of a 25-year-old; and we have much to be thankful that, as a result of economic and medical advances, most of us will now exceed the Psalmist’s fourscore years. We will, nevertheless, all still die, safe in the Christian hope that death is not the end—and, until that day comes, we must never again allow the State to prevent us from living.

 

Previous

Next