Letter to the Editor: Response to the Last Editorial

Letter to the Editor Response to Last Edition’s Editorial Dear Editor, Thank you very much for your Christian charity and spirited editorial, Friday 8th October 2021, ( E.C. No.8090).  Also thanks are due to you for reprinting so much excellent reformed evangelical...

Letter to the Editor: The Murder of Sir David Amess

Murder of Sir David Amess Dear Editor, I grieve at the loss of a friend and former Party colleague Sir David Amess, MP who was murdered in an increasingly dangerous world. In the 70s I worked with David in the Young Conservatives before he became an MP and he was...

Reformation Sunday Advert

LETTER TO THE EDITOR:                        15 October 2021. My ‘Advert’ titled “Reformation Sunday 31 October” said, “The Church of England should still celebrate this 500th year since Martin Luther declared at the ‘Diet of Worms’ in 1521, “Here I stand. God help...

Leicester Diocese Illogical

Letter to the Editor Leicester Diocese Illogical   Sir, Leicester Diocese’s decision on 9 October to replace its traditional Parishes with ‘Minsters' is both spiritually and financially illogical.  The Church of England’s own growth report ‘From Anecdote to...

Barnabas Fund Reports: Turkey Escalates Airstrikes Against Christians in Syria & Iraq

Barnabas Fund Reports Turkey Escalating Airstrikes Against Christians and other Minorities in Syria and Iraq Turkey has escalated a supposedly anti-terrorist military campaign in Syria and Iraq which appears to be targeting Christians and other minorities. A spate of...

Should I Stay or Should I Go? Gospel-Driven Anglicanism Part 4

Should I Stay or Should I Go? By the Revd Dr Mark Pickles Part 4 Gedaliah is appointed governor and we read that Jeremiah purposely chooses to live amongst “those of the poorest of the land who had not been taken into exile in Babylon” (40:7). Things have taken a turn...

466th Anniversary of the Martyrdoms of Latimer & Ridley

466th Anniversary of the Martyrdoms of Latimer & Ridley Saturday, 16 October marked the 466th anniversary of the martyrdoms of Bishops Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Ridley.   They were burned at the stake after being found guilty of heresy due to their refusal to...

Clive West Memorial Trust Lecture: John Yates III to Speak

Clive West Memorial Trust Lecture  Revd Dr John Yates III to Speak The annual Clive West Memorial Lecture will be held on Thursday, 11 November at 19:30 at St Nicholas’ Church, Lisburn Road in Belfast.  This year’s speaker is the Revd Dr John Yates III, Rector of Holy...

Book Review: Bleeding for Jesus

Bleeding for Jesus John Smyth and the cult of the Iwerne Camps Andrew Graystone Darton, Longman and Todd, 2021 (ISBN: 9781913657123, 250pp, £12.99) This book is the latest instalment of a long-running tragedy. It comes six years after the author was first made aware...

School Pupils Across the Country Memorise Passages from BCP for £1,000 Prize

School Pupils Across the Country  Memorise Book of Common Prayer Passages  £1,000 Prize for Winner By Tim Stanley Hundreds of school pupils across the country are busy this term studying prayers and readings from the 1662 Book of Common Prayer in a bid to win a prize...

Scripture or the Three-Legged Stool? by Mark Pickles

The question of ultimate authority is crucial for any church or denomination but is of particular significance within Anglicanism.

The Thirty-nine Articles are unequivocal the Scripture is to be the Church’s final and ultimate authority.  

Article VI states that “Holy Scripture  all things necessary to salvation; so that whatsoever is not read therein nor may be proved thereby, is not the be require of any man, that it should be believed as an article of Faith, or be thought requisite or necessary to salvation”.

This article reveals the nuanced Anglican understanding of Scripture that wee will look at more fully shortly, however for now we note that it points us to Scripture as that which reveals the gospel to us.

Article XX addresses the question of the authority of the Church, “The Church hath power to decree Rites and Ceremonies and authority in Controversies of the Faith: and yet it is not lawful for the Church to ordain any thing that is contrary to God’s Word written, neither may it so expound one place of Scripture that be repugnant to another.  Wherefore although the Church be a witness and a keeper of holy Writ, yet, as it ought not to decree anything against the same …”

Article XXI speaking of General Councils, “… and when they be gathered together … they may err and sometimes have erred, even in things pertaining unto God.  Wherefore things ordained by them as necessary to salvation have neither strength nor authority, unless it may be declared that they be taken out of holy Scripture”.

The Articles are clear that Scripture has authority over Church Tradition and Councils, and that no church council or synod should ever ordain anything contrary to Scripture.  Church Councils can and do err but Scripture is inerrant and the bar against which everything must be checked.

The question of ultimate authority in many ways brings us to the heart of the battle for the soul of Anglicanism.  My point here is simply that historic Anglicanism has always been clear that Scripture and Scripture alone is our ultimate authority.  

The so-called “Three-legged stool” has come to be spoken of as depicting authentic Anglicanism’s approach to this question of authority.  The three-fold sources of authority:  Scripture, Tradition, and Reason are to be held in balance in coming to a common mind on matters of faith and conduct.  This has never been the position of historic Anglicanism and it is certainly not that understanding of authority revealed in the Articles.  Rather, historic Anglicanism greatly prizes both tradition and reason not least because they are invaluable tools in helping us interpret Scripture correctly.  We want to mine the vast resources and treasures of the Christian Church to help us understand God’s Word correctly and we want to be rigorous in applying our minds, the God-given faculty of reason again to help us understand and interpret God’s Word in the right way.

However, what the Articles make abundantly clear is that if there is ever a dispute between tradition and Scripture, Scripture alone is inerrant, infallible, and authoritative.  Church Councils can and do err but Scripture does not.

Excerpted from The Revd Dr Mark Pickles’ book, Gospel-Driven Anglicanism, pages 28-30.