NEW

Letter to the Editor: Prayers for the Dead at Remembrance Services

Prayers for the Dead at Remembrance Services   Sir, Remembrance Sunday is an important and poignant landmark in our nation’s annual calendar, and a day to reflect, give thanks and pray for peace. We see church and civic life combine in silence and remembrance, as...

Evangelical Theological College of Asia

Evangelical Theological College of Asia Have you ever wondered if there was a sound reformed theological training institution in Asia?  The Evangelical Theological College of Asia is just such a school.  It is located in Singapore and its faculty are mostly from...

Prudence Dailey’s Commentary: Should Women Be Afraid of Men?

Prudence Dailey's Commentary Should Women be Afraid of Men? Recently, someone I used to work with shared on her Facebook page a link to an article from The Times magazine by the feminist writer Caitlin Moran. The substance of Ms Moran’s piece—rhetorically addressed to...

FIEC Updates Its “Values Statement”

FIEC Updates Its “Values Statement” The Fellowship of Independent Evangelical Churches recently updated its “Values Statement.”  It is well-worth your time to read.  There are FIEC affiliated congregations in England, Scotland, and Wales.   1. God-honouring and...

Death of LENORA HAMMOND

Lenora Hammond 1960-2021 Mrs Lenora Hammond, wife of Frontline Fellowship founder Dr Peter Hammond, died on 9 November.  She was six days short of her sixty-first birthday.  Frontline Fellowship is headquartered in Cape Town, South Africa. Mrs Hammond was born into a...

Archbishops’ Appointments Secretary to Retire

Archbishops’ Appointments Secretary to Retire “The Archbishops of Canterbury and York have paid tribute to the service of Caroline Boddington, who has announced she will be leaving the National Church Institutions (NCIs) at the end of 2021 after 17 years as the...

Book Review: The Lullingstone Secret

The Lullingstone Secret Jill Masters Wakeman Press, 2021 (ISBN: 9781913133115, 97pp, £5.95) Lullingstone Villa in Kent is a fascinating site to visit whatever one’s awareness of ancient history and is lavishly curated by English Heritage. Since its excavation in the...

Book Review: The Welsh Methodist Society

The Welsh Methodist Society The Early Societies in South-West Wales 1737-1750 Eryn M. White University of Wales Press, 2021 (ISBN: 9781786835796, 350pp, £24.99) In many respects, the church in Britain continues to live off the puttering afterglow of the eighteenth...

Eastern Rite Catholics: What Are They?

Eastern Rite Catholics What Are They? Former Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali’s recent defection to Rome has highlighted earlier efforts of the Roman Catholic Church to bring other ecclesiastical jurisdictions into its orbit.  There are a total of twenty-three which have...

Book Review: Bleeding for Jesus

Bleeding for Jesus

John Smyth and the cult of the Iwerne Camps

Andrew Graystone

Darton, Longman and Todd, 2021 (ISBN: 9781913657123, 250pp, £12.99)

This book is the latest instalment of a long-running tragedy. It comes six years after the author was first made aware of the abuse of John Smyth and four years after the resulting Channel 4 News reports which he assisted. Since then, Graystone has received further contact from Smyth victims, which has allowed him to flesh out various aspects of the narratives. The main period of abuse in England seems to have been 1978-1982, followed by further abuses in Zimbabwe and South Africa. Meanwhile, the narrative of the handling (or mishandling) of the legacy largely picks up in 2012 and is ongoing nine years later. 

To have all the public details of the Smyth matter brought together in a comprehensive fashion is valuable. Too much discussion of the matter has been sustained by short, guarded statements, hushed conversations over dinner party tables, ‘nod and wink’ confidences, social media frenzy, and gratuitous speculation. To his credit, Graystone states clearly and unequivocally the nature of the abuse: Smyth’s brutal caning of dozens of young men with the warped justification that the activity was a means of sanctification. The perversion of Christian discipline which this represented was recognised by many of those involved by early 1982 and stated explicitly in a memo written by Mark Ruston and circulated to trustees of the Iwerne Trust. 

Graystone’s opinion is that Smyth’s abuse was motivated in great measure by the theological distinctives of evangelicalism. He alleges that although Smyth was married (and apparently happily so), his abusive behaviour was the expression of a homosexual inclination unnaturally constrained by his religious environment. In this respect the book veers close to polemic and unhelpfully weaponises a case of serial abuse for deployment in the church’s internal war over sexual ethics. The vast majority of evangelicals, including those with genuine homosexual attraction, do not become abusers. Smyth’s case cannot be generalised in the expansive manner which Graystone attempts.

Despite evidently wide research, the book is also hampered by several factual errors and misapprehensions: the Titus Trust works in independent schools, not just boarding schools; GAFCON has not threatened to break from the Anglican Communion – it is the majority of the Anglican Communion; Iwerne Camps no longer exist, having been wrapped up this year; etc. Alongside such straightforward errors are a swathe of surprisingly unreferenced assertions: Stott’s declaration of his asexuality; directives for the self-identification of ‘gay’ evangelicals; Winchester College forfeit systems; the self-segregation of VPS staff at SU conferences; etc. 

Finally, the errors and assertions are completed with a thick layer of Graystone’s own prejudicial opinion; the gospel taught by SU camps was ‘narrow’; male church leaders form a ‘gentleman’s club’; diversity of sexual expression is ‘beautiful’; and, above all, that Iwerne constituted a sect and (as the title states) a cult. These overreaches undermine the book. Graystone is not alone in seeming to feel justified in using Smyth to indict the whole evangelical world; many commentators have jumped on the bandwagon to denounce their favoured figure of hate. This behaviour is a grave disservice to victims of the abuse and an ill-judged muddying of waters might otherwise have been significantly cleared.

The next main stage in this sorry affair is likely to be the publication of the Makin Report in 2022, the independent inquiry commissioned by the Archbishops’ Council. Whether that will serve to bring any closure, especially to the victims, remains to be seen.

Edward Keene, Little Shelford

Previous

Next