NEW

Anglican Futures: Anglican Alphabet Spaghetti

Anglican Futures Anglican Alphabetti Spaghetti A dummies guide to the plethora of organisations and acronyms linked to faithful Anglicans in the UK and Europe. I once spent some time around military personel.  Everything had its own TLA (Three Letter Acronym) right...

Canterbury Tales: Favourite Bible Stories Retold by Archbishop Justin Welby

Canterbury Tales Favourite Bible stories retold by Archbishop Justin Welby The Good Samaritan A man was going down from Jerusalem to Jericho, when he was attacked by robbers. They stripped him of his clothes, beat him and went away, leaving him half dead, halfway...

Anglican Mission in England Elects Two Suffragan Bishops

Anglican Mission in England Elects Two Suffragan Bishops The Anglican Mission in England (AMiE) met in Synod on 18 June.  While there, they elected two suffragan bishops to aid Bishop Andy Lines in providing episcopal oversight for the overall work.  Bishop Lines also...

Pride Flags Causing Conflict at Christian School

Pride Flags Cause Conflict at Christian School Conflict has broken out in a Christian school in Oxfordshire over the display of “Pride” flags. The institution in question is Kingham Hill School.  The same Trust (Kingham Hill Trust) oversees Oak Hill College, an...

Prayer Book Society Raising Funds to Put BCPs in the Hands of Choristers

Prayer Book Society Raising Funds to Put BCPs in the Hands of Choristers The Prayer Book Society, which will soon celebrate its 50th Anniversary, is raising funds to put a special edition BCP into the hands of junior choristers around the nation.   The idea came to...

Book Review: Reimagining Britain by Justin Welby

Reimagining Britain Foundations for Hope Justin Welby Bloomsbury, 2018, new edn. 2021 (ISBN: 978-1-4729-8497-5, 322pp, £12.99) The Archbishop of Canterbury has made several notable political interventions recently, including over ‘partygate’ and the Rwanda deportation...

Birthday of Anglicanism in America

Birthday of Anglicanism in America By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins June 16, 1607 was the birthday of Anglicanism in America. On this day Captain John Smith and 104 others celebrated the Lord’s Supper when they arrived safely in Jamestown, Virginia. Jamestown was the...

Barnabas Fund Report: Two ChiBok Girls Found

Barnabas Fund Reports Two Chibok Girls Found After 8 Years 24 June 2022 Two women, who were among hundreds of schoolgirls abducted by Boko Haram from the Nigerian town of Chibok eight years ago, have been found. Hauwa Joseph was discovered among a group of other...

New Bishop-elect for the Diocese of Cashel, Ferns & Ossory

Church of Ireland News New Bishop Elected for Cashel, Ferns & Ossory The Church of Ireland diocese of Cashel, Ferns, and Ossory now has a bishop-elect.  The Venerable Adrian Wilkinson, Archdeacon of Cork, Cloyne, and Ross was elected to succeed the Rt Revd Michael...

Editorial: Lessons to be Learned from the American Pro-Life Movement

Editorial Lessons to be Learned from American Pro-Life Movement Friday, 24 June 2022, the Feast of St John the Baptist, will be a date which will live in infamy amongst the supporters of abortion.  On that date, the US Supreme Court, overturned the precedent set by...

Book Review: Bleeding for Jesus

Bleeding for Jesus

John Smyth and the cult of the Iwerne Camps

Andrew Graystone

Darton, Longman and Todd, 2021 (ISBN: 9781913657123, 250pp, £12.99)

This book is the latest instalment of a long-running tragedy. It comes six years after the author was first made aware of the abuse of John Smyth and four years after the resulting Channel 4 News reports which he assisted. Since then, Graystone has received further contact from Smyth victims, which has allowed him to flesh out various aspects of the narratives. The main period of abuse in England seems to have been 1978-1982, followed by further abuses in Zimbabwe and South Africa. Meanwhile, the narrative of the handling (or mishandling) of the legacy largely picks up in 2012 and is ongoing nine years later. 

To have all the public details of the Smyth matter brought together in a comprehensive fashion is valuable. Too much discussion of the matter has been sustained by short, guarded statements, hushed conversations over dinner party tables, ‘nod and wink’ confidences, social media frenzy, and gratuitous speculation. To his credit, Graystone states clearly and unequivocally the nature of the abuse: Smyth’s brutal caning of dozens of young men with the warped justification that the activity was a means of sanctification. The perversion of Christian discipline which this represented was recognised by many of those involved by early 1982 and stated explicitly in a memo written by Mark Ruston and circulated to trustees of the Iwerne Trust. 

Graystone’s opinion is that Smyth’s abuse was motivated in great measure by the theological distinctives of evangelicalism. He alleges that although Smyth was married (and apparently happily so), his abusive behaviour was the expression of a homosexual inclination unnaturally constrained by his religious environment. In this respect the book veers close to polemic and unhelpfully weaponises a case of serial abuse for deployment in the church’s internal war over sexual ethics. The vast majority of evangelicals, including those with genuine homosexual attraction, do not become abusers. Smyth’s case cannot be generalised in the expansive manner which Graystone attempts.

Despite evidently wide research, the book is also hampered by several factual errors and misapprehensions: the Titus Trust works in independent schools, not just boarding schools; GAFCON has not threatened to break from the Anglican Communion – it is the majority of the Anglican Communion; Iwerne Camps no longer exist, having been wrapped up this year; etc. Alongside such straightforward errors are a swathe of surprisingly unreferenced assertions: Stott’s declaration of his asexuality; directives for the self-identification of ‘gay’ evangelicals; Winchester College forfeit systems; the self-segregation of VPS staff at SU conferences; etc. 

Finally, the errors and assertions are completed with a thick layer of Graystone’s own prejudicial opinion; the gospel taught by SU camps was ‘narrow’; male church leaders form a ‘gentleman’s club’; diversity of sexual expression is ‘beautiful’; and, above all, that Iwerne constituted a sect and (as the title states) a cult. These overreaches undermine the book. Graystone is not alone in seeming to feel justified in using Smyth to indict the whole evangelical world; many commentators have jumped on the bandwagon to denounce their favoured figure of hate. This behaviour is a grave disservice to victims of the abuse and an ill-judged muddying of waters might otherwise have been significantly cleared.

The next main stage in this sorry affair is likely to be the publication of the Makin Report in 2022, the independent inquiry commissioned by the Archbishops’ Council. Whether that will serve to bring any closure, especially to the victims, remains to be seen.

Edward Keene, Little Shelford

Previous

Next