We Wish You a Merry Saturnalia: Northern Churchman

We Wish You a Merry Saturnalia? The Northern Churchman There is a familiar feel to this time of year. The Christmas advertising on television, the darker evenings, the Carol Services – and the inevitable scoffers who call the Christmas story a myth. Not ‘Once in Royal...

Mark Pickles: The Story of Two Trampolines

Gospel-Driven Anglicanism By the Revd Dr Mark Pickles The Story of the Two Trampolines:  A passage that is frequently referred to during times of great revival is Isaiah 64:1-3:  “Oh that you would rend the heavens and come down, that the mountains might quake at your...

Ten Thousand Bibles for London’s Children

TBS Auxiliary Meets Ten Thousand Bibles For London’s Children The Greater London Auxiliary of the Trinitarian Bible Society was delighted to report at its Annual Meeting held on 15 November that over 10,000 Bibles have been distributed to London schools since the...

Good News for Egypt’s Christians

Barnabas Fund Reports Good News for Egypt’s Christians The government of Egypt licensed 125 churches and church-affiliated buildings on 14 November. It is the 24th batch of approvals made since the government committee overseeing the licensing process started work in...

Church Society’s Response to MP Ben Bradshaw

Church Society’s Response to MP Ben Bradshaw In the aftermath of Desmond Tutu’s daughter being refused permission to preside at a funeral in a Church of England parish, Labour MP Ben Bradshaw told The Guardian that the “C of E must move swiftly to welcome lesbian...

Collins: Who’s Your Righteousness?

Who’s Your Righteousness? By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins Who’s your righteousness? "The Lord our Righteousness" was the sermon preached March 20, 1757 at St. Mary's Church in Oxford. It offended nearly everyone that day and William Romaine was invited to never preach...

Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction Act of 1963

Ecclesiastical Jurisdiction Act of 1963 Persons Against Whom Proceedings May be Instituted. Proceedings under this Measure may be instituted against an archbishop, any diocesan bishop or any suffragan bishop commissioned by a diocesan bishop or any other bishop or a...

Editorial: Joy to the World Cup

Editorial Joy to the World Cup The result of the 2022 FIFA World Cup is already in. And it appears the Church of England has lost. The latest advice from the Church of England’s Support Hub is for parishes to consider the timing of Christmas Carol Services to avoid...

Symes to Step Down from Anglican Mainstream Leadership

Symes to Step Down from Anglican Mainstream Leadership By Chris Sugden Andrew Symes is to stand down as Executive Secretary of Anglican Mainstream on January 1, 2023, after nearly ten years in post. Rev Symes, 56, who had earlier served with Crosslinks in South...

Retired Bishop Given Life Suspension

Retired Bishop Given Life Suspension By George Conger The former Bishop of Ramsbury has been suspended for life from the ordained ministry after he admitted to having sexually abused two women. The Daily Mail reported the Rt Rev. Peter Hullah had been the subject of...

Letter: Monsignor Nazir-Ali’s Long Discomfort with Anglican Doctrine

Nazir-Ali’s Long Discomfort with Anglican Doctrine


Dear Sir,

I am grateful to Dr Ro Mody for his informative piece on Rome and Justification (EC, June 17th). It deserves wider dissemination within the Church.

In an article published on the First Things website on April 1st(!), former Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali explained the process by which he moved to Roman Catholicism. He freely quotes from ecumenical agreements on justification between the RC Church and Protestant denominations. Dr Mody’s piece goes a long way in explaining how Rome can use similar words to formulate an agreement, whilst maintaining her own definition of such words to retain her doctrine intact. It appears this nuance has passed by Dr Nazir-Ali; all he can see in Dr Mody’s article is a pointless regurgitation of sixteenth-century disputes

In his April 1st essay, Michael Nazir-Ali provides a full and frank account of his difficulties with contemporary Anglicanism, in its lack of authority and its uncritical assimilation of society’s standards, especially in sexual ethics. He also explains why he views Rome as a better model for upholding biblical and patristic teaching.

Most revealing, however, is his opinion of the Reformation, and reformed teaching on the sacraments: “I had long been uncomfortable with the Anglican (and general Reformation) teaching that there are only two sacraments, baptism and the Eucharist. The other sacraments are believed to be misreadings of the apostles’ teaching or, at best, states of life allowed by the Scriptures. It is argued that they are not to be held as ‘proper’ sacraments, for they have no visible sign directly instituted by Christ.”

He then makes a special plea for marriage and ordination, that they in particular ought to be considered ‘sacraments of the gospel’.

Nazir-Ali does not state for how long he had been feeling this discomfort with Anglican teaching on two sacraments only; might it precede the major battles over human sexuality or the formation of GAFCON? It would be reasonable to suppose that it did encompass some of the time he was a Bishop of the Church of England and a figurehead in the Global Anglican movement.

This is a most serious revelation:

  • that one charged with defending the truth and ordaining those to teach such doctrine did himself dissent from the teaching of Article 26,
  • that a leading figure critical of Anglican provinces for moving away from the Church’s teaching on marriage had private reservations on the Church’s teaching on the character of marriage, 
  • that one who was central in a movement built on the Jerusalem Declaration and its affirmation of the 39 Articles, secretly wished that at least one of the Articles had said something different.

If dissent from doctrinal authority and agreed standards were key reasons for Dr Nazir-Ali’s departure from Anglicanism, then it would appear this dissent was present internally in his mind as well as externally within the institutions. Did he ever mention to GAFCON leaders how uncomfortable he felt affirming one thing on their platform while believing something different?

By his own admission, Michael Nazir-Ali wasn’t troubled merely by trends in contemporary Anglicanism, he was also troubled by the teaching of historic Anglicanism.



Michael Andrews