Book Reviews: Baptism & Confirmation & Patterns for Baptism

Book Reviews Baptism and Confirmation Church House Publishing, 2022 (ISBN: 9780715123522, 468pp, £40) Patterns for Baptism Church House Publishing, 2022 (ISBN: 9780715123492, 392pp, £25) These handsome volumes are the latest additions to Common Worship, the Church of...

The Diverse Excellencies of Jesus Christ: Gospel-Driven Anglicanism

Gospel-Driven Anglicanism By the Revd Dr Mark Pickles The Diverse Excellencies of Jesus Christ  The American Theologian and Pastor, Jonathan Edwards (1703 -1758), once preached a sermon entitled “The Admirable Conjunction of Diverse Excellencies in Jesus Christ”. The...

The Cancelling of the Creator

The Cancelling of the Creator The headline from a national newspaper popped up on my phone: “Daniel Radcliffe is surely the world’s most ungrateful man”. It’s not a title many would be scrambling to win for themselves, but the opinion-piece made the case. Daniel...

Melville-Knox Christian School Opens in Aberdeen

Melville-Knox Christian School Opens in Aberdeen Melville-Knox Christian School Aberdeen officially opened on Monday 7th November after years of prayer, planning and organisation. We give thanks to the Lord that we have been able to reach this significant milestone;...

Barnabas Report: At Least 21 Christians Killed in Mozambique

Barnabas Report At Least 21 Christians Killed in Mozambique During October At least 21 Christians have been killed by Islamist extremists in violent attacks throughout October in northern Mozambique. Jihadists set fire to a church building and several houses in the...

Sanctuary Foundation Offers Free Advent Resource

Sanctuary Foundation Offers Free Advent Resource  Sanctuary Foundation has been aiding those trying to offer assistance for those fleeing the war in Ukraine through its, “Homes for Ukraine” scheme.  The charity has been serving as a liaison by resourcing hosts and...

Annual Clive West Memorial Lecture Set for Belfast

Annual Clive West Trust Lecture Set for Belfast The 2022 Clive West Trust Lecture will take place on Thursday, 22 November at St Nicholas’ Church on the Lisburn Road in Belfast at 19:30. This year’s featured speaker is the Revd Dr Tim Ward.  Ward earned his PhD from...

Church of England Council Rejects Croft’s Position

Church of England Evangelical Council Rejects Croft’s Position In a press statement following the pronouncements of Steven Croft, Bishop of Oxford, the Church of England Evangelical Council repudiated the departure of biblical teaching advocated by Croft. It said,...

On Transubstantiation: Reformation Anglicanism

Reformation Anglicanism On Transubstantiation By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins Transubstantiation became the official doctrine of the Roman Catholic Church at the Fourth Lateran Council that began, November 11, 1215. The Council of Trent in 1551 went on to confirm the...

Oxford Good Stewards Trust Announced in Response to Bishop of Oxford’s Revisionism

St Paul’s Banbury, Oxford Answers Bishop and Announces  The Oxford Good Stewards Trust The Revd Dan McGowan, Vicar of St Paul’s, Banbury in Oxford Diocese has answered Bishop Croft’s revisionist declarations about same-sex matters and announced the formation of The...

Editorial: A Tautological Bishop?


A Tautological Bishop?

In October, Dr Jo Bailey Wells, the current Bishop of Dorking in Guildford Diocese, was announced as the Anglican Communion’s first Bishop for Episcopal Ministry. Dr Bailey Wells, a former chaplain to Archbishop Justin Welby, will begin her new role in January 2023.

According to Anthony Poggo, the Secretary General of the Anglican Communion, this post is designed to “foster a collaborative, engaged, enriched fellowship among the bishops of the Anglican Communion, inspiring ever greater companionship, learning and interchange between provinces. This will build on the outcomes of Lambeth ’22, taking forward the Lambeth Conference Calls as well as the renewed relationships between bishops across varying provinces. It will also help to equip bishops for ministry, supporting them not only in their particular contexts but also for engaging in the wider Communion.”

Is the tautology of the title ‘Bishop for Episcopal Ministry’ evidence of a navel-gazing Church irreversibly turned inwards on itself?  Has no bishop ever been for Episcopal Ministry until now? Presumably at present, Dr Bailey Wells will be Bishop for Episcopal Ministry only in those Anglican provinces that accept women in Episcopal Ministry. There is no indication of the clamour for such a figure beyond the Anglican Communion Office; how many bishops worldwide wanted this?

At a time when Church of England parishes must adhere to the Safer Recruitment process whereby “our recruitment and selection processes are inclusive, fair, consistent and transparent,” little of this is evident within the press release. We are merely told that this post “was agreed by the Anglican Communion’s Standing Committee” at its last meeting in London, and that it “has been created to build on the success of this year’s Lambeth Conference.” Alas, this proclaimed ‘success’ is nowhere defined.

The press release notably gave little information on how widely this position was advertised throughout the Communion, the application process, and when interviews took place. Neither did it explain how the post is funded. The bare announcement was accompanied by the customary slew of congratulatory paragraphs from usual suspects. 

In the name of upholding Episcopal Ministry, Dr Bailey Wells is confined to an episcopal ministry unlike any other in the Anglican Communion. She will have no diocese and no parishes. She will pastor no incumbent clergy and no parishioners. The liturgical roles unique to a bishop, ordination and confirmation, will not be hers in the normal course of events – the laying off of hands?

Discipline and defending the faith are also part of Episcopal Ministry, but there is no indication that she will have any such power in relation to any errant bishop. In short, she is shorn of regular Episcopal Ministry in order to promote Episcopal Ministry. No doubt this makes perfect sense within the corridors of the Anglican Communion Office.

A Bishop’s ministry is exercised in fellowship with the whole church, clergy and people. Once more it can be asked, what is to be gained in removing a bishop from a geographically-defined pastoral ministry, and from the whole people of God? It is not clear from the role as described why it had to be a bishop appointed to such a position. Could these functions not be carried out by a lay person with comparable expertise? Why must they always require a flash of purple and episcopal stipend?

One argument might be made is that Dr Bailey Wells has experience of Episcopal Ministry and brings that perspective to the role. However, that unique selling point is being lost; she is now being removed from Episcopal Ministry in order to be for Episcopal Ministry. 

Might bishops on the ground not find support in their ministry from their colleagues in the same province, their Archbishop or Primate, or retired bishops? Would a local input not be more relevant to the growing dioceses of the Global South, rather than imposing the mindset of managed decline so prevalent amongst western bishops? 

This enthusiastically-announced position appears to diminish Episcopal Ministry as a ministry to the whole church by taking it away from the whole church. It also distorts the nature of Episcopal Ministry by removing the essential aspects of pastoral oversight to local churches and clergy.

Can an Episcopal Ministry distorted still be Episcopal Ministry promoted?