NEW

Archbishop Calls for Listening and Unity

Archbishop Calls for Listening and Unity Justin Welby Appeals to General Synod Before Vital Debate The Archbishop of Canterbury has appealed to General Synod for greater listening and unity. He addressed the membership ahead of their three-day gathering, expected to...

Anglican Myth #3: The Bishop is the Focus of Unity

Anglican Futures Anglican Myth #3: The Bishop is the Focus of Unity "Plural Truth", "Walking Together", call it what you like, in the Archbishop of Canterbury's understanding of the church, God no longer speaks clearly through the Scriptures, instead he speaks through...

St Helen’s Bishopsgate “Pauses Contributions to Common Fund”

St Helen’s Bishopsgate “Pauses Contributions to Common Fund” The Standing Committee of the PCC of St Helen’s Bishopsgate has written to the Bishop of London to make plain their theological opposition to the proposed same-sex blessings proffered by the House of...

Hull Parish Rejects Authority of Archbishop of York Over False Teaching

Hull Parish Rejects Authority of Archbishop of York Over False Teaching St Andrew’s Kirk Ella has written a very direct letter to the Archbishop of York about his support for the same-sex blessings proposals.  In the letter, they pull no punches and announce that with...

Barnabas Fund Report: African Hospitals Give Thanks for PPE as Ebola Breaks Out in Uganda

Barnabas Fund Report African Hospitals Give Thanks for PPE as Ebola Breaks Out in Uganda Christian hospitals in Africa have given heartfelt thanks for a huge consignment of personal protective equipment (PPE) shipped by Barnabas Aid’s medical.gives programme. “We want...

His Majesty’s Declaration Pertaining to the Use and Understanding the Articles of Religion

His Majesty’s Declaration Pertaining to the Use and Understanding the Articles of Religion Words do have meaning and particularly when they pertain to how we are to understand the doctrines of the Church.  In an earlier era, under a different monarch named Charles,...

Keene Review: Finding Your Best Identity

Finding Your Best Identity A short Christian introduction to identity, sexuality and gender Andrew Bunt IVP, 2022 (ISBN: 9781789744200, 90pp, £8.99)   The most casual glance at biblical passages such as Matthew 6 or 1 John 2 indicates that ‘the world’ is entirely...

CEEC Calls for Action

CEEC Calls for Action  Offers the Church of England a Better Way Forward After failing to provide a quick substantive answer to the Blessings Proposals  by the House of Bishops, the CEEC has responded in a very clear way in stating its opposition to what has been...

Thomas Cromwell: The Man Behind the Curtain

Thomas Cromwell The Man Behind the Curtain By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins So many “Thomases” in the 16th century, it’s hard to keep them straight! Thomas Cromwell was beheaded July 28, 1540 by order of King Henry VIII for the crime of treason and heresy, but his real...

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated The Revd Rob Munro was consecrated as Bishop of Ebbsfleet on Thursday 2 February in a service at Canterbury Cathedral.   In keeping with the complementarian understanding of ministry, Bishop Munro was consecrated to...

Binary or Non-Binary by Revd Dr Rohintan Mody

BINARY OR NON-BINARY?

By the Revd Dr Rohintan Mody

This week, a big story has hit the mainstream media:  the story of the first non-binary vicar. According to the media, the Revd Bingo Allison is, to his knowledge, the first openly non-binary minister to be ordained in the Church of England.

Bingo Allison wants all to use the plural pronoun “they” when referring to him. Quite apart from the grammatical confusion, I shall continue to refer to Revd Allison as “he” and “him” for the theological reasons below.

According to the media interviews, Revd Allison comes from a traditional, orthodox Christian family background and had a conservative view on human sexuality. However, he says that he has been on a “journey”. He records that during his ordination training, Revd Allison, changed his mind because of his new understanding of Genesis 1:27 which says: “So God created man in his own image, in the image of God he created him; male and female he created them.” (ESV). Revd Allison believes that since God says “from maleness to femaleness” rather than “men and women”, God was guiding him to this new truth about himself, that is, a non-binary truth about his real identity (both male and female). According to non-binary theory, human beings can be “gender fluid” both male and female, at one and the same time, indeterminate and not fixed, and therefore the use of the preferred pronoun “they.” Hence, Revd Allison says he is now “non-binary.”

Let’s consider carefully Revd Allison’s biblical and theological argument. First, the context of Genesis 1 is clear: It is about the ordered (not fluid) creation of the cosmos by the Word of God. Secondly, Genesis 2:23 interprets Genesis 1:27’s “male and female” as being quite specifically Man and Woman: “Then the man said, “This at last is bone of my bones and flesh of my flesh; she shall be called Woman, because she was taken out of Man.” (ESV). Thirdly, in Genesis 1:27, says “male and female” not “from maleness to femaleness”. “Male and female” are not fluid, abstract, philosophical concepts in the Bible, but physical and sexual terms in Hebrew understanding; “male and female” refers to men having male genitalia and women having female genitalia. Fourthly, God’s reason and goal in creating men and women as exclusively male or female, was that men and women would pair off, get married, and have children: “be fruitful and multiply and fill the earth” (Genesis 1:28, cf. 2:24-25 ESV.) This not merely a divine blessing or a command, but God’s creation ordinance: That is, it is something that is written by God into human beings’ DNA. We are “hard-wired”, so to speak, by the Creator as either men with male physical organs, or women with female physical organs. 

This is just the way it is. If we don’t like God’s binary design, we might as well complain to God “why didn’t you create me with two heads or three arms?” Well, the answer to that God just didn’t create us with the two heads or three arms or non-binary. We can’t just choose or prefer to have two heads or three arms or be non-binary.  God has created us binary, and genetics is destiny.

If the media reports are factually accurate, then may I request that the Bishop of Liverpool (Revd Allison’s Diocesan) helps Revd Allison with his personal issues and tells him to stop giving interviews to the media about his non-binary theology, because it is unbiblical and false teaching. The Bishop has promised to teach the truth and drive away false teaching. All Bishops must fulfil their consecration vows.

Dr Mody is a Lecturer in New Testament Studies.

Previous

Next