NEW

Keene Review: Finding Your Best Identity

Finding Your Best Identity A short Christian introduction to identity, sexuality and gender Andrew Bunt IVP, 2022 (ISBN: 9781789744200, 90pp, £8.99)   The most casual glance at biblical passages such as Matthew 6 or 1 John 2 indicates that ‘the world’ is entirely...

CEEC Calls for Action

CEEC Calls for Action  Offers the Church of England a Better Way Forward After failing to provide a quick substantive answer to the Blessings Proposals  by the House of Bishops, the CEEC has responded in a very clear way in stating its opposition to what has been...

Thomas Cromwell: The Man Behind the Curtain

Thomas Cromwell The Man Behind the Curtain By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins So many “Thomases” in the 16th century, it’s hard to keep them straight! Thomas Cromwell was beheaded July 28, 1540 by order of King Henry VIII for the crime of treason and heresy, but his real...

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated The Revd Rob Munro was consecrated as Bishop of Ebbsfleet on Thursday 2 February in a service at Canterbury Cathedral.   In keeping with the complementarian understanding of ministry, Bishop Munro was consecrated to...

Hypocrisy of Authoritarian Bishops

The Hypocrisy of Authoritarian Bishops  Part 2 By the Revd Dr Lee Gatiss Sophistry I wonder if the bishops who wrote this report did so with a straight face? They tell us that church blessings are not pronouncements, and approval cannot be inferred from them. They...

South Sudan Primate Welcomes Church Leaders but Remains Firm on Biblical Marriage

South Sudan Primate Welcomes Church Leaders but Remains Firm on Biblical Marriage The Pope, the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Moderator of the Church of Scotland, the Revd Dr Iain Greenshields, visited South Sudan in the first weekend of February to participate in...

Welby Chooses Disestablishment Over Global Breakup

Welby Chooses Disestablishment over Global Breakup Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby has indicated that he prizes the unity of the global Anglican Communion over the continued established status of the Church of England, in surprising comments that were reported...

Conservative Bishops Reaffirm Church’s Teaching on Marriage

Conservative Bishops Reaffirm Church's Teaching on Marriage Fourteen Bishops of the Church of England have published "a relatively short theological summary of the doctrine of marriage as the Church of England has received it, and how it relates particularly to...

Pilgrim’s Process: Trials & Challenges

Pilgrim’s Process By the Revd Dr Peter Sanlon Trials and Challenges As we travel to our heavenly city we face trials and challenges that can feel like they are more than we will be able to bear. The sufferings of this present age are considerable. When we are alone...

New Bishop to the Archbishops Announced

New Bishop to the Archbishops Announced The Rt Revd David Urquhart has been announced as the new Bishop to the Archbishops of Canterbury and York, succeeding Dr Emma Ineson who has been appointed Bishop of Kensington. In this role, he will work directly for both...

An Insincere Jargon Filled Betrayal of the Gospel

“An Insincere Jargon-filled Betrayal of the Gospel”

Bishops Same-Sex Proposals Slammed

The Bishops of the Church of England have published their proposals on human sexuality, to conservative dismay. Dissatisfied progressives have responded by tabling a motion to General Synod asking for same-sex marriage proposals to be brought to the Synod meeting in July.

The bishops will issue an apology to Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transexual, Queer, Intersex, and other people (LGBTQI+) for the “rejection, exclusion, and hostility” they have faced in churches. In the document Prayers of Love and Faith they “offer the fullest possible pastoral provision without changing the Church’s doctrine of Holy Matrimony for same-sex couples through a range of draft prayers, known as Prayers of Love and Faith, which could be used voluntarily in churches for couples who have marked a significant stage of their relationship such as a civil marriage or civil partnership.” 

New pastoral guidance will replace Issues in Human Sexuality, which binds clergy to celibacy outside of heterosexual marriage.

The bishops assert that “The formal teaching of the Church of England as set out in the canons and authorised liturgies – that Holy Matrimony is between one man and one woman for life – would not change.” They offer, however, services of dedication and prayers of blessing on same-sex couples who marry or couples who enter civil partnerships. These liturgical offerings would be “would be voluntary for clergy to use”.

These proposals, which follow a six-year Living in Love and Faith process of discussion, will be outlined in a report to the General Synod, meeting in London next month.

Dr Lee Gatiss of Church Society slammed the proposals as “an insincere jargon-filled betrayal of the gospel”

He asked, “How can we promote and bless and celebrate and give thanks for things which God has not blessed?

“It is sleight of hand at best and a downright lie at worst to claim that allowing for the blessing of same-sex marriage relationships in church is not a change in the Church’s doctrine of marriage. Sex outside of heterosexual marriage is sinful, and has always been recognised as so by the church in every place and in every time. It has been recognised as so by the General Synod. To change this, in order to bless homosexual relationships, is not just a piece of minor tinkering.

“The great theologian Thomas Aquinas said that if someone teaches that God is not a Trinity, or that sexual immorality is not a sin, then they are a heretic (see his commentary on Titus 3). That has always been the universal teaching of the church. To accept this change is to change our doctrine and practice, because our practice reflects our doctrine. It would make us heretics, just as surely as if the bishops told us we could use Unitarian prayers and were at liberty to argue against the doctrine of the Trinity. The bishops can’t make it a non-change simply by stating that this change is not a change. For us to swallow such casuistry requires far too much mental gymnastics. It convinces no-one.

“Perhaps this is the art of compromise, doing something that will please no-one? Liberals are not happy because the proposals do not bring in gay marriage in full, and the kind of radical inclusion they were looking for. Conservatives are not happy because the proposals would enshrine heresy in the church. Those who treasure unity above all are askance at all the disunity. So should we be content that nobody gets everything they want, and try to make it work?

“The main question ought to be: does this please God, or not? But God seems to have been sidelined in the Church of England, in favour of a political balancing act which aims simply to keep the show on the road long enough for Justin Welby to still be allowed to do the Coronation as leader of the established church. 

“There has been no convincing argument made for us to change our doctrine and practice . . . I think it’s insulting that clergy are all forced to study the Bible and theology before being ordained and yet the bishops have made no attempt to argue for a change here biblically or theologically, preferring sentimentality, pragmatics, and cultural accommodation. Scripture remains our standard”. (full statement at churchsociety.org)

Dr Ian Paul (psephizo.com) made similar points, “First, those writing this statement (and so perhaps those agreeing it?) appear to have abandoned any need to offer something coherent. The different elements of the document are so manifestly contradictory that I found the piece astonishing. Is this where we have got to as a Church?

Secondly, there is simply no attempt to acknowledge, let alone engage with, developed, theologically rooted, statements from the past. . . Third, the engagement with scripture is just woeful. Simplistic, proof-text ideas are plucked out of context.”

However ex-evangelical and LGBT+ campaigner Jayne Ozanne described the blessings as “breadcrumbs” and “the minimum they can do”. She has tabled an amendment to General Synod asking the House of Bishops “to end discrimination on the grounds of sexuality by bringing forward immediate legislation to provide for equal marriage in church for review at the July 2023 group of sessions”.

Interviewed by William Crawley on BBC Radio 4’s Sunday programme, Archbishop Stephen Cottrell was pressed on whether the Church still taught that gay sex is a sin. He replied, “Well, what we are saying is that physical and sexual intimacy belongs in committed, stable, faithful relationships and therefore where we see a committed, stable, faithful relationship between two people of the same sex, we are now in a position where those people can be welcomed fully into the life of the Church, on their terms.”

London clergyman Dr Paul Blackham reflected on those responsible for this teaching, “In one sense they seem to be well-meaning, emotionally vulnerable people who… perhaps…  have never fully grasped what the Christian Faith is all about – or what we need to share with a lost and broken world.

“People are so lost, so hurting, so broken – and they need something so much greater than the powerless message these bishops seem to be offering right now…

“Their policies genuinely sound like HR documents from the BBC or from any other Matrix-corporation of this moment … All they can offer is a thin, religious veneer.

“Listening to them makes me understand more of why attendance in the Church of England is plummeting. It is as if they themselves don’t REALLY believe that Jesus is a SAVIOUR or that Church is the only safe Ark to escape from the judgement of God – from hell and condemnation.”

Previous

Next