Archbishop Calls for Listening and Unity

Archbishop Calls for Listening and Unity Justin Welby Appeals to General Synod Before Vital Debate The Archbishop of Canterbury has appealed to General Synod for greater listening and unity. He addressed the membership ahead of their three-day gathering, expected to...

Anglican Myth #3: The Bishop is the Focus of Unity

Anglican Futures Anglican Myth #3: The Bishop is the Focus of Unity "Plural Truth", "Walking Together", call it what you like, in the Archbishop of Canterbury's understanding of the church, God no longer speaks clearly through the Scriptures, instead he speaks through...

St Helen’s Bishopsgate “Pauses Contributions to Common Fund”

St Helen’s Bishopsgate “Pauses Contributions to Common Fund” The Standing Committee of the PCC of St Helen’s Bishopsgate has written to the Bishop of London to make plain their theological opposition to the proposed same-sex blessings proffered by the House of...

Hull Parish Rejects Authority of Archbishop of York Over False Teaching

Hull Parish Rejects Authority of Archbishop of York Over False Teaching St Andrew’s Kirk Ella has written a very direct letter to the Archbishop of York about his support for the same-sex blessings proposals.  In the letter, they pull no punches and announce that with...

Barnabas Fund Report: African Hospitals Give Thanks for PPE as Ebola Breaks Out in Uganda

Barnabas Fund Report African Hospitals Give Thanks for PPE as Ebola Breaks Out in Uganda Christian hospitals in Africa have given heartfelt thanks for a huge consignment of personal protective equipment (PPE) shipped by Barnabas Aid’s programme. “We want...

His Majesty’s Declaration Pertaining to the Use and Understanding the Articles of Religion

His Majesty’s Declaration Pertaining to the Use and Understanding the Articles of Religion Words do have meaning and particularly when they pertain to how we are to understand the doctrines of the Church.  In an earlier era, under a different monarch named Charles,...

Keene Review: Finding Your Best Identity

Finding Your Best Identity A short Christian introduction to identity, sexuality and gender Andrew Bunt IVP, 2022 (ISBN: 9781789744200, 90pp, £8.99)   The most casual glance at biblical passages such as Matthew 6 or 1 John 2 indicates that ‘the world’ is entirely...

CEEC Calls for Action

CEEC Calls for Action  Offers the Church of England a Better Way Forward After failing to provide a quick substantive answer to the Blessings Proposals  by the House of Bishops, the CEEC has responded in a very clear way in stating its opposition to what has been...

Thomas Cromwell: The Man Behind the Curtain

Thomas Cromwell The Man Behind the Curtain By the Revd Canon Chuck Collins So many “Thomases” in the 16th century, it’s hard to keep them straight! Thomas Cromwell was beheaded July 28, 1540 by order of King Henry VIII for the crime of treason and heresy, but his real...

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated

New Bishop for Complementarian Churches Consecrated The Revd Rob Munro was consecrated as Bishop of Ebbsfleet on Thursday 2 February in a service at Canterbury Cathedral.   In keeping with the complementarian understanding of ministry, Bishop Munro was consecrated to...

An Unmutual Flourish

Guest Op-Ed

An Unmutual Flourish?

The Maidstone Commitments, Bishop Rod Thomas’ recent document, is difficult to read. Not in the sense of receiving and understand the text, but in terms of determining its purpose and timing within the life of the Church of England.

Is it a final legacy piece from a Bishop approaching retirement? It seems unusual for a bishop for determine policy for his successor, that the next occupant inherits a policy not of his devising but of his predecessor’s. Of course, that assumes there will be a successor.

Is it more about succession than legacy? Will the first Bishop of Maidstone to provide alternative episcopal oversight be the last? Can the document then been seen as a plea to the Church establishment to continue to provide this episcopal ministry, with the assurance that the parishes will ‘play nicely’ within the system?

Certainly no-one could quibble with the need for better Safeguarding policies and practices, providing “safe pathways for raising concerns”. That issue remains perennial and paramount, particularly for Conservative Evangelicals in the light of the Smyth/Fletcher revelations.

What is unusual is the provision that those parishes who do not accept the ordination of women announce it publicly: “to state openly their theological convictions over men’s and women’s ministry”. This is one issue among many amongst the various and varying parishes in the Church of England as a whole; yet by highlighting this to the exclusion of all others, it makes one issue the only issue, colouring everything else a parish does in its proclamation of the gospel. Does a church service require an Advisory Warning to ensure persons of a nervous disposition can turn away? 

It is difficult to see the spirit of the much-vaunted Mutual Flourishing in this approach. It appears one-sided to ensure complementarian parishes advertise their view on this issue, when other parishes do not have to highlight some of their doctrines and practices, in particular those where they clearly deviate from Scripture and the Thirty-nine Articles.

For example, would it not be more honest and transparent for a self-proclaimed ‘inclusive’ church to clearly and unequivocally state in its publicity, ‘We do not hold to biblical standards on sexuality and the orthodox Christian view of marriage’? Should certain so-called ‘modern’ churches declare, ‘We do not believe Christ rose bodily from the grave’? Should we ask some Anglo-Catholic parishes to outline which of the Thirty-nine Articles they wish to have re-written, deleted, or otherwise ignored?

It seems a complementarian view of women’s ordination is one of the ‘blasphemous fables and dangerous deceits’ of contemporary Anglicanism, so abhorrent that it must come with a spiritual health warning. A new form of social distancing is now required, lest the very concept pollutes the ears and infects the minds of potential visitors to these churches.

It remains to be seen whether this concession will be the price required to secure succession in Maidstone.

The unsigned author is an observant cleric long in Holy Orders.